You are here
AI Resources
This page collects further resources on generative AI, both in licensed resources and as part of broader critical literacy around AI.
Assessing AI in Licensed Resources
Library Freedom Project AI in Vendor Tools Database
- This resource is a detailed compilation of generative AI tools and integrations in vendor products, collected by the Library Freedom Project. Information includes the language model used, if known; whether the AI can be turned off; and vendor statements regarding data collection and accuracy, where available. Licensed CC-BY-NC by Library Freedom Project.
Questions to Ask Vendors about AI
- This list of questions can be used by library staff when determining whether to license a product that includes an AI tool, as well as when engaging in conversations and negotiations with the vendor. Licensed CC-BY-NC by Library Freedom Project.
AI in Library Licensed Platforms Rubric
- This rubric, developed by Vancouver Island University Library, is an assessment tool for library staff who want to evaluate AI in library-licensed platforms. It considers dimensions including cost, quality, integrity, data security, and social and environmental concerns. Licensed CC-BY by Vancouver Island University Library.
- This checklist, developed by the AI Response Team at the University of Toronto, was developed to respond to AI tools in databases, promote iterative decision making around AI tools in vendor products, and facilitate safe and informed use of AI in library collections. Licensed CC-BY by University of Toronto.
Navigating the AI Maze: Evaluating Emerging Tools in Academic Databases
- This article outlines the process that Illinois State University took to create an evaluation tool for evaluating vendor AI platforms. The complete AI evaluation tool is provided, with outcomes of three initial evaluations discussed in depth. Supplementary guidance that could be customized to instsitutional policy is also provided Authored by Grace Norris, Grace Allbaugh and Eric Wiley; published open access and licensed CC-BY by Internet Reference Service Quarterly.
Further Learning on AI in Licensed Resources
AI Tools for Hospital Librarians
- This guide, created by the NNLM Region 7's AI Community of Practice, provides a short primer on AI tools for hospital librarians, including a shortlist of AI tools currently available in vendor products and their costs if applicable. Attribute any information from this page to NLM.
A Librarian's Guide to AI in Academic Search Tools
- This May 2025 article offers understandings of some of the AI techologies used in library vendor products, including large language models (LLMs), retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), and semantic search. It also explores how integration of these AI tools affects the interpretability and reproducibility of search results. Authored by Aaron Tay; published and licensed CC-BY-NC by Katina Magazine.
Deep Dive Into Three Academic Search Tools
- This May 2025 article, a companion to the article above, reviews the retrieval-augemented generation (RAG) tools in Primo Research Assistant, Web of Science Research Assistance, and Scopus AI. Authored by Aaron Tay; published and licensed CC-BY-NC by Katina Magazine.
Do the New AI Features in these Databases Actually Help Researchers?
- This September 2026 article presents a detailed review of the AI features and their functionality in EBSCO, ProQuest, and JSTOR interfaces. Authored by Aster Zhao; published and licensed CC-BY-NC by Katina Magazine.
Resources on Critical AI Literacy for Library Workers
OCUL Machine Learning and AI Report
- This report, which comes out of a survey conducted by OCUL's AI and Machine Learning Program in 2025, captures library workers' thoughts on and familiarity with AI technologies.
Values-Aligned AI in Academic Libraries - Findings from the OCUL Focus Group Report
- This report summarizes feedback from focus groups held by OCUL's AIML Program. It provides an in-depth look at the ethical considerations, risks, and opportunities that library workers feel generative AI and machine learning tools offer, and highlights participants' desire for values-aligned AI tools and uses.
OCUL AI Tools for Academic Libraries
- This blog series, written by OCUL AI Program Manager Kari Williams, offers a practical look at and evaluations of various categories of generative AI tools and their usage in academic libraries. Topics include research assistants, time management optimizers, and transcription services. The series aims to empower library professionals to make informed, confident decisions about AI technologies.
Comparing AI chat tools and PubMed for medical literature searches
- This substantiative investigation compares six AI chat tools (ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, Gemini, OpenEvidence, and Perplexity) to each other and to PubMed to assess their utility in medical literature searches, including counts of real and hallucinated searches. Published and licensed CC-BY by the Journal of the Medical Library Association.
Evaluating a large language model's ability to answer clinician's requests for evidence summaries
- This article reveals the results of a team of information professionals and clinicians at Vanderbilt University Medical Center into the performance of an internal AI chat tool in answering clinical questions in comparison with medical librarians' gold-standard evidence syntheses. Published and licensed CC-BY by the Journal of the Medical Library Association.
Critical AI in Higher Education Toolkit
- This toolkit from the Library Freedom Project frames the conversation around ethical and environmental concerns about AI for those working in higher education and concerned about adoption of AI technologies without critical thought. It includes a section on AI in library vendor tools for library workers. Licensed CC-BY-NC by Library Freedom Project.
Futurescape Libraries AI Toolkit
- This toolkit is designed for leaders in research libraries who want to integrate the ARL/CNI AI Scenarios into ongoing planning activities, including annual operating plans, strategic reviews, or cross-institutional conversations. It contains reflection prompts, templates, and facilitator guidance for conversations, among other resources. Licensed CC-BY by Keith Webster and ARL/CNI.
